| Ranking | School | 4-year graduation rate |
| 1 | Carleton College | 91% |
| Northfield, MN | ||
| 2 | Georgetown University | 91% |
| Washington, DC | ||
| 3 | University of Notre Dame | 91% |
| Notre Dame, IN | ||
| 4 | Colgate University | 90% |
| Hamilton, NY | ||
| 5 | College of the Holy Cross | 90% |
| Worcester, MA | ||
| 6 | Columbia University | 90% |
| New York, NY | ||
| 7 | Davidson College | 90% |
| Davidson, NC | ||
| 8 | Harvey Mudd College | 90% |
| Claremont, CA | ||
| 9 | Pomona College | 90% |
| Claremont, CA | ||
| 10 | Princeton University | 90% |
| Princeton, NJ | ||
| 11 | Washington University in St. Louis | 90% |
| St. Louis, MO | ||
| 12 | Kenyon College | 89% |
| Gambier, OH | ||
| 13 | Middlebury College | 89% |
| Middlebury, VT | ||
| 14 | Swarthmore College | 89% |
| Swarthmore, PA | ||
| 15 | United States Naval Academy | 89% |
| Annapolis, MD | ||
| 16 | Boston College | 88% |
| Chestnut Hill, MA | ||
| 17 | Dartmouth College | 88% |
| Hanover, NH | ||
| 18 | Haverford College | 88% |
| Haverford, PA | ||
| 19 | Johns Hopkins University | 88% |
| Baltimore, MD | ||
| 20 | Lafayette College | 88% |
| Easton, PA | ||
| 21 | Tufts University | 88% |
| Medford, MA | ||
| 22 | Vanderbilt University | 88% |
| Nashville, TN | ||
| 23 | Vassar College | 88% |
| Poughkeepsie, NY | ||
| 24 | Williams College | 88% |
| Williamstown, MA | ||
| 25 | Amherst College | 87% |
| Amherst, MA |